He summarizes Viveiros de Castro, that typically, humans see humans as humans, animals as animals and spirits in the case they see them as spirits. Predatory animals and spirits see humans as prey animals, whereas prey animals see humans and spirits as predatory animals. However, animals and spirits do not see themselves as such, but as anthropomorphic beings, experiencing their habits and characteristics in cultural ways.
Their social system is organized as human institutions, with shamans, feasts, rites, villages and so on. Bodily attributes, as for instance claws or furs, are perceived as body decoration. Their food is regarded as human food, for example, a jaguar would see blood as manioc beer.
Anthropology and the Cognitive Challenge Anthropology and the Cognitive Challenge
On the other hand, the body as clothing must not be equated to a naked anatomy as the biological conception of body, but to a habitus , in other words, as an expression of their affections, of what they eat, how they move, where they live, how they communicate and so on Viveiros de Castro, and Descola In fact, there might not be an original state of nature, naturalness or animality, should we think of a world in which beings always commence living through culture.
Modern multiculturalism founds one nature for a multiplicity of cultures whereas multinaturalism conceives one culture for multiple natures. Descola tempers that binary oppositions do not constitute the source of the problem, but the belief that their content is universal. This is a query to be explored in its fullest potential. It is through this framework that one realizes the importance of cognitive sciences for modern ontology.
Modern naturalism conceptualizes a physical continuity across organisms and at the same time mobilizes mental faculties as resources to emphasize differences among living beings. The implication is such that naturalism can only grant personhood to animals phylogenetically close enough to humans to be theoretically or empirically capable of catching up with human cognitive complexity to a considerable extent. Descola recalls that even the field of contemporary animal ethics seems to argue along predictable directions traced by naturalism. On the borders of our humanity lie non-human individuals with enough cognitive similarities to us to be eligible to occupy the status of persons.
This is a challenge primatology should choose to accept and one it cannot accomplish without sociocultural anthropology. Animal cultures should not be conceived as an intertwined mixture of two fixed pure forms, but as genuine hybrids capable of redefining the content of crystallized Nature-Culture poles. However, for animal cultures to reveal their full potential, crossed concerns are required from primatology and anthropology.
Life sciences ought to systematically include the question of meaning in its research agenda, while anthropology should strive for a non anthropocentric approach to culture. Furthermore, non-Western conceptualizations of human-animal relationships open up Western concepts for examination. In an ontology in which the original condition between humans and animals is culture, not nature, it is not to doubt animals are persons.
Personhood as a characteristic of cultural beings is not automatically taken as a line of inquiry by cultural primatology when primate cultures are studied.
Comparison in Anthropology : The Impossible Method
Because modern naturalism differentiates beings in terms of cognitive capacities, animal personhood can only be granted to individuals with enough cognitive similarities to us to be eligible to occupy the status of persons. Primatology and anthropology should accept the challenge of assessing the deepest implications of the idea of animal culture.
This pledges for a redefinition of the categories in which we have been grounding our understanding of humans and non-human animals. Boesch C Is culture a golden barrier between human and chimpanzee? Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews 12, 82— Darwin C The descent of man and selection in relation to sex.
Vol I. London: John Murray.
Unlocking potential with the best learning and research solutions
De Lilo C, Visalberghi E Transfer Index and mediational learning in tufted capuchins Cebus apella. International Journal of Primatology 15, — Descola P Paris: Gallimard. Fragaszy D Making space for traditions. Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews 12, 61— Fragaszy DM, PerryS The biology of traditions: Models and evidence. Fragaszy D, Visalberghi E Socially biased learning in monkeys.
Learning and Behavior 32, 24— Gallois DT De arredios a isolados: perspectivas de autonomia para os povos indigenas recem-contatados. Geertz C The interpretation of cultures: Selected essays. New York: Basic. Gieryn TF American Sociological Review 48, — Haraway DJ Primate visions: Gender, race, and nature in the world of modern science.
New York: Routledge.
Simians, cyborgs, and women: The reinvention of nature. Primate archaeology. Nature , — Howard CV Hutchins E Cognition in the wild. The role of cultural practices in the emergence of modern human intelligence. Ingold T An anthropologist looks at biology.
Man 25, — General introduction. In Companion encyclopedia of anthropology: Humanity, culture and social life pp. London, New York: Routledge. Humanity and Animality. Introduction to culture. Introduction to social life. Kuhn TS Reflections on my critics. Musgrave Eds. Cambridge: University Press. The structure of scientific revolutions.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Latour B We have never been modern. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press. On interobjectivity. Mind, Culture, and Activity 3, — Lestel D The Biosemiotics and Phylogenesis of Culture. Social Science Information 41, 35— Etho-ethnology and ethno-ethology. Social Science Information 45, — Les origines animales de la culture. Paris: Flammarion.
Anthropology and the Cognitive Challenge - Maurice Bloch - Google книги
McGrew WC A clearly written, sophisticated summary of and prospectus for a flourishing current field of anthropological research. A clearly written, sophisticated summary of and prospectus for a flourishing current field of One of the world's most distinguished anthropologists proposes that cognitive science enriches, rather than threatens, the work of social scientists.
One of the world's most distinguished anthropologists proposes that cognitive science enriches, Through critical revision of Foucault's investigation of ethics, Faubion develops an original program of empirical inquiry into the ethical domain. Through critical revision of Foucault's investigation of ethics, Faubion develops an original A new theory of human behaviour, with three core ingredients: language, interaction, and social accountability.
A new theory of human behaviour, with three core ingredients: language, interaction, and social Comparative and critical, Anthropology and Economy offers a uniquely cross-cultural view of economy. Toggle navigation.
- Strategic Preaching: The Role of the Pulpit in Pastoral Leadership?
- Anthropology and the Cognitive Challenge;
- Poems Seven: New and Complete Poetry.
- Saturday Morning (Anthology by Edited by Maxine Thompson for Saturday Morning Literary Workshop!
- New Departures in Anthropology;
New to eBooks. New Departures In Anthropology Series.